Hi Bernard,
First, I'm a big fan. I've read the entire Sharpe and Saxon Chronicles twice. Thanks so much for that. That said, I’m working on a book project myself. Its subject is the Irish Diaspora in America. If I ever finish, it’ll be part family history, part Irish history, and part travel narrative. Right now I’m deeply immersed in the family history part, and it seems my 3rd great-grandfather, Thomas Farrell, joined the British Army at age 17 in March of 1811. He enlisted for unlimited service in the 29th Worcestershires in Mullingar, Co. Westmeath. Ultimately, he died in Mauritius in 1830, likely of disease, but not before he had a son while on garrison duty in Waterford in 1826. This child was Godfrey Farrell, my 2nd great grandfather. Godfrey emigrated to Boston during the famine years, and here I am!
So here’s my question. I understand that at least 30% of Wellington’s magnificent Peninsular Army was Irish, mainly Catholic Irish, at least in the ranks. Given the history of British colonization of Ireland, and the festering wound of the United Irishmen of 1798 and 1803, why did so many young Irish Catholic men volunteer for British service? The poverty bit is obvious. Three meals a day vs. starvation is a no-brainer. But studies show that the Irish peasant at the time was far healthier than his continental counterpart because of the potato. When not afflicted with blight, it was a staple teeming with essential nutrients, far more than the grain/vegetable diet of European subsistence farmers. Some sources say that the Irish were heavily recruited by the British because they were so big and healthy. So why did Harper do it? Why did Thomas Farrell join up? Simply for adventure? Is the animosity toward the English narrative overblown? I’d be grateful for any explanations you might have, in addition to source material.
By the way, I grew up in the Boston area and vacationed in Chatham as a kid. I love it there. My mum lives in East Dennis now, and I’m on the Cape a lot. It’s great off-season. The summers are a little too busy for me.
Thanks again.
Dave Farrell