Bernard,
I just wanted to drop you a note in appreciation, I have read much of your work, but am now reading my way through the Saxon Stories collection, and I think, perhaps, it is your best ever.
On European Steel
I do appreciate that you have researched history and technology to the extent that you even understand historical European sword making. You are the only author I have read who has accurately described the making of twisted soft and hard steel swords in Europe. I am very fond of George R. R. Martin, and think he is a great writer, but it does distress me whenever he talks of “re-forging” valerian steel (a watered steel) by melting it down and re-casting it in the shape of a new sword – which, of course, would only leave you with a blade of pig-iron. It is a small matter, yet if you are going to write novels all about swords, it is better, I think, to know how swords are made.
Stirrups?
And while I am in such a picky pedantic mood, please let me pose a small question to you. In a number of places in the Saxon Stories you mention riders using stirrups. Some might question whether stirrups were in use in Britain by the late ninth century. The use of stirrups was starting to spread across Europe by then, and had, for instance, reached Sweden. The use of stirrups would revolutionize warfare from the 10th century on – shifting the balance of strength from infantry to heavy cavalry. This would last until the English longbow shifts the balance back to foot soldiers, something you describe so well in The Grail Quest books.
However, I think a number of historians would at least raise an eyebrow at your suggestion that they were in common use in Britain by the 870 or so. Also, forgive me if I am wrong, but now I vaguely remember you mentioning stirrups in the Warlord Chronicle -- Arthur used stirrups? Again, forgive me if I have mis-remembered this and wrongly accuse you. If you did not put Arthur in stirrups, you must be the only author who did not.
Anyway, the stirrup thing is a small niggle. I do love your books, as I do love those of Martin, so I think I will send a copy of this missive to him.
Please, both of you -- Live Long, and Keep Writing.
Cruin MacGriogair.