Sir I was wondering what your reaction to the field test of tap loading from descriptions found in your books. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pvc86ggLUY4. The gentleman who posted this and was part of the group said he couldn’t find any historical evidence the tactic was used. Was there a prescient? Personally I think if not snug against the powder the ball would be wobbly in flight and miss the hair of the Frenchman’s mustache! I also had questions if this could was used with true rifles (1853 Enfield 1861 Springfield etc) if it worked I would assume it made an adoption to Crimea and conversely the droves of British ex-soldiers coming to the United States from (1840-1860) would have brought it with them. Seeing as how we as Civil War reenactors use an offshoot of tapload because we aren’t allowed to use the rammer, it just got me thinking. My thoughts are, if tried with a miniball the cone would lodge in the barrel and you’d go up in smoke. But what are yours. Cheers, Adam Azzalino
My thoughts are that it must have been very rare, but I have seen it mentioned. I doubt it would work much of the time (certainly not with a rifled barrel), and perhaps it was something to be used only in a desperate situation where there wasn't time to load properly and the purpose of the exercise is to create a lot of noise fast!